Your guide to Christmas treats!

Sugar, Spice, and Everything Nic-e

Be Happy Pie Company

🧁 As we get closer to holiday parties and festive gatherings, check out our list of places to pick up the perfect snacks to bring along!

The Evansville Region is filled with local bakeries and restaurants crafting pastries that make every morning feel a little brighter. From handcrafted macarons and cranberry pear pies to gluten-free cupcakes and creative seasonal specialties, there’s a sweet bite waiting around every corner. As you explore, you’ll find that each bakery brings its own flair! Some are rooted in tradition, others are reinventing classics with a local twist. To make your next pastry run even easier, we’ve rounded up the must-try spots serving up the freshest, most crave-worthy treats in the region. 

Pangea Kitchen
111 S Green River Road

Pangea Kitchen

Pangea Kitchen is serving up holiday sweetness with treats that are as beautiful as they are delicious. Their Vanilla Bean Tres Leches offers a creamy, dreamy bite soaked with rich flavor, while the Coconut Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting brings a perfect balance of fluffy texture and decadent frosting. And for the ultimate festive gift, the  12 Days of Macarons Gift Box (pictured) features an assortment of colorful, handcrafted macarons that make the season feel extra special.

PS, orders must be placed by December 19th!

Order Today

Artboard 7
2818 Mt Vernon Ave B

Be Happy Pie Company

🥧 Be Happy Pie Company is bringing all the holiday cheer with a menu that’s fully stocked and ready to sweeten any celebration. And just in time for the season, their December Pie of the Month, Cranberry Pear (pictured), arrives on December 1st, blending bright, festive flavors into one unforgettable slice of holiday joy.

Order Online

Christmas Joy Cookies
Haubstadt, IN

Belle's Bakery

🍪 These sweet mini cookie packs from Belle’s Bakery are perfect for stockings. Even Santa would approve!

Place Order

Artboard 9
4111 Merchant Dr., Newburgh, IN

Bea Sweet Treats 

 

Bea Sweet Treats, the mother-and-daughter duo behind some of the region’s most delightful desserts, has its front case fully stocked and ready to sweeten your day. From gluten-free cupcakes and macarons to a variety of other tempting treats, there are plenty of options for everyone to enjoy.

Be sure to order ahead and plan for your Christmas treats pickup on Tuesday the 23rd or Wednesday the 24th.

Learn More